Songs NIN Has NEVER Played Live
 
Page: <  First... 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

04/12/09 8:11 PM

0001 posted:
swindley posted:

The Life You Didn't Lead

A Message to No One

What? I've never heard of these songs. Please enlighten me smiling smiley

They were b-sides from "With Teeth". They were never confirmed to even have been recorded, but on the "With Teeth" lyrics poster, it shows those two songs along with a song called "The Warning" without any lyrics. As far as we know, it has nothing, everything, or somewhere in between to do with the "Year Zero" song of the same name.

 

04/15/09 6:18 AM

Guybrush86 posted:
gracie posted:
Cedocore posted:
i really want to hear We're In This Together.

Yep, I would like to hear/see We're In This Together live but it's very very unlikely it will be played live. The chorus line is long - a real strain on the vocal chords.

They played when I saw them in Glasgow in 2007

[www.youtube.com]

 

04/17/09 8:53 PM

Wow never played the perfect drug live, it's one of my favourite NIN song

 

04/18/09 12:59 PM

I would love to hear Perfect Drug live. Its my favorite.

 

04/30/09 3:09 AM

Living On Prayer
Ice Ice Baby
My Humps
Opps I did It Again...

alright, I'll stop now. smiling smiley

 

04/30/09 7:30 PM

jason11497 posted:
I WOULD LOVE TO HEAR "Physical [You're So]" FROM BROKEN OR "DEAD SOULS" FROM THE CROW SOUNDTACK

Physical has been played live with Adam and the ants (its their song) I have it on a boot somewhere.

Dead souls I think has been played as well. It's also a cover.


I second whoever called for kinda I want to. I know trent thinks its not that great but some of us out here love it.

As for the perfect drug well he is going on tour with stephen perkins. and no one plays off beat wierdness quite like perkins....

 

05/07/09 1:53 PM

Why doesnt anyone want to hear zero-sum live? Seeing that song live would make my life!

 

05/07/09 1:58 PM

VorticistsSuite posted:
Why doesnt anyone want to hear zero-sum live? Seeing that song live would make my life!

I would love to see that live also!

 

05/07/09 2:32 PM

VorticistsSuite posted:
Why doesnt anyone want to hear zero-sum live? Seeing that song live would make my life!

because.

 

05/07/09 2:38 PM

CharmlessMan posted:
VorticistsSuite posted:
Why doesnt anyone want to hear zero-sum live? Seeing that song live would make my life!

because.
I second this.grinning smiley

 

05/07/09 2:52 PM

Come on how could anyone rather hear the perfect drug live over zero sum? The perfect drug = worst nin song

 

05/07/09 7:45 PM

what no "purest feeling"


i would still love to see "a perfect drug" and
"all that could have been" live.

 

05/07/09 11:15 PM

Trent said that "Lights In The Sky" is going to be played on the upcoming tour so... get ready to take that off the list! WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

 

05/07/09 11:47 PM

purest feeling is bad. i dunno why people wanna hear that song. i burst out laughing every time that sax comes on.

 

05/09/09 9:12 AM

Well, they played Gone, Still last night - looks like a few songs might get taken off this list during this tour.

 

05/09/09 10:46 PM

Lights in the Sky debut tonight.

 

05/09/09 11:05 PM

CharmlessMan posted:
purest feeling is bad. i dunno why people wanna hear that song. i burst out laughing every time that sax comes on.

I love purest feeling! I know it should sound cheesy, but it sounds "pure" to me smiling smiley

 

05/10/09 12:51 AM

As much as I'm glad there is a thread covering this topic, it was put together the worst way possible and it is beyond effectively useless, it is counter-productive. The initial step of creating a list in the format of "none of the songs on the albums x,y, or z have been played live EVER. PERIOD. . . . EXCEPT for these songs:" is like directing traffic with a flag that's red and green on both sides.

That coupled with people's broken memories and lies they now believe about what they know they swear they heard eight years ago. . . I understand the difficulty of putting this type of thing together, but that difficulty may be an impossibility.

 

05/10/09 12:31 PM

swindley posted:
Seems this is one of the most asked questions of NIN fans: "Has _______ ever been played live?" Well don't bother asking again! Just refer to this handy-dandy list. Trust me: if its on this list, it's never been played (at least in a public setting).

I'll update as songs are debuted.





-----------------------------
HAVE NEVER BEEN PLAYED
-----------------------------

A Warm Place

The Perfect Drug



Where Is Everybody?

I'm Looking Forward To Joining you finally

10 Miles High

Appendage

Underneath it All

Ripe (with Decay)



Gone, Still

The Persistance of Loss

Leaving Hope

And All That Could Have Been



All the Love in the World

Sunspots (note: played in sound check at the Edmonton, AB show in Nov. 2005)

The Life You Didn't Lead

A Message to No One



My Violent Heart

Another Version of the Truth

Zero-Sum



GHOSTS:
2-4
7-13;
15
16
18
20
22-24
26, 27, 29, 30
33-38



Lights in the Sky

Corona Radiata (NOTE: Sample played during stage change between songs)

The Four of us are Dying

Demon Seed

-----------------------------------------------
THE FOLLOWING SONGS DEBUTED/RESURFACED IN 2008
-----------------------------------------------

Vessel [07/28/08]

The Warning [07/25/08]

God Given [07/25/08]

Meet Your Master[07/29/08]

The Greater Good [07/26/08]

In This Twilight [07/26/08]



GHOSTS:
1 [07/26/08]
5 [07/28/08]
6 [07/28/08]
14 [08/15/08]
17 [07/29/08]
19 [07/26/08]
21 [07/29/08]
25 [07/26/08]
28 [08/13/08]
31 [07/25/08]
32 [08/12/08]



999,999 [07/25/08]

1,000,000 [07/25/08]

Letting You [07/25/08]

Discipline [07/25/08]

Echoplex [07/25/08]

Head down [07/25/08]


-----------------------------------------------
THE FOLLOWING SONGS DEBUTED/RESURFACED IN 2007
-----------------------------------------------

Last (debuted on the 2007 European tour)



Heresy (debuted on the 1994 TDS tour; resurfaced on the 2007 European tour)

The Becoming (debuted on the 1994 TDS tour; resurfaced on the 2007 European tour)



We're In This Together (debuted on the 2007 European tour)

Pilgrimage



Adrift and At Peace (pPayed at the Bridge School Benefit)



HYPERPOWER! (Played in Brisbane, AUS)

The Beginning of the End [2/19/07]

Survivalism [3/8/07]

The Good Soldier [5/9/07]

Me, I'm Not [5/9/07]

Capital G [5/13/07]

The Great Destroyer [8/1/07]


----------
NOTES:
----------
NOTE: Four tracks from Ghosts were played at the 7/19/08 Secret Show in LA. No solid confirmation on which four is currently available, but speculation says it was 1, 6 or 8, 31, and a fourth unknown.

NOTE: Nothing from Fixed, Things Falling Apart, or other remix "singles" has been played, other than the list of non-LP songs below.

ADDENDUM: Samples from the Happiness in Slavery remix on Fixed were featured in the Pukkelpop 2007 performance of The Great Destroyer.

NOTE: A Warm Place has NEVER been played live, despite some bootlegs having it listed. For example, "Nails in My Head" from New Year's 1995 in Detroit has A Warm Place listed but the track is actually The Downward Spiral (without vocals).


--------------------------------------------------------
The following non-LP songs have been played live
--------------------------------------------------------

Get Down, Make Love

Closer to God

Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now)

Dead Souls

Burn

Deep

Not So Pretty Now

Non-Entity

You can take "Lights In The Sky" off of the list now smiling smiley

 

05/10/09 1:41 PM

Given the fact Trent busted out "Metal" and "Now I'm Nothing" I'd suspect this list of "never played songs" may just be irrelevant after this tour, save for the remixes.

Perfect Drug? Just maybe...

 

05/10/09 1:57 PM

Excuse me, but there are 145 nrs never played. just check nin songs



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 05/10/2009 01:58PM by pukkelpop.

 

05/10/09 2:12 PM

An incredible live show website NIN Tour History is great for listing songs and is regularly updated to include the songs they have never played. Really easy to track which songs you have seen and where.

 

05/10/09 2:24 PM

just kinda taking this moment to once again beg, plead, grovel, and kiss any ass necessary to experience perfect drug in kansas city. thank you for your time.

 

05/10/09 9:49 PM

pukkelpop posted:
Excuse me, but there are 145 nrs never played. just check nin songs

Well I wouldn't really count every remix and (version) as their own NIN song. But I don't think it's unreasonable to guess that all the proper album tracks and singles may just turn up.

 

05/10/09 9:54 PM

/prays for Supernaut

 

05/11/09 9:59 PM

VorticistsSuite posted:
Come on how could anyone rather hear the perfect drug live over zero sum? The perfect drug = worst nin song

I have said this before and I will say it again. The only part of TPD I would love to hear is the drum solo, and I would love to see it inserted into the instrumental part of HiS. There is a way to ease it in there and then go back to HiS that would sound really freaking good.

 

05/11/09 10:37 PM

Bridge posted:
Erase posted:
c0rnfl4ke posted:
Hey, there's an interview with Ilan at drumchannel.com where he speaks about NIN...He even reveales that they're gonna play Demon Seed on the forthcoming tour and in the video he plays the beginning of the song on his drums !!!

That was awesome, i hope they play it on this tour!! grinning smiley

fuck.. I couldnt agree more!! ^^ is there a link for that video??... oh yeah found it! nevermind.


could u post the link to the interview pleaase!!?.. i didn't find it... spinning smiley sticking its tongue out

 

05/12/09 11:21 AM

TPD, have to side with trent, he's got a good drummer, but you'd need Neil Peart to pull that one off, if its possible



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 05/12/2009 01:10PM by JT_Fragile.

 

05/12/09 7:32 PM

needs to be adjusted as he played lights in the sky live in Tampa

Also.... IF HE PLAYS PERFECT DRUG ON THIS TOUR SOMEBODY BETTER GET THAT CRAP ON YOUTUBE!

what's the deal? Does he not like that song?

 

05/12/09 11:04 PM

the perfect drug<333

 
nin forums : General Tour Discussion : Songs NIN Has NEVER Played ...
Page: <  First... 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum. Please log in at the top of the page.
 
terms of use | privacy policy