Funny how they said that, and then changed it because it wasn't a popular record reception-wise. They let others cloud their judgement. Look at the score now.
Rolling Stone: The Smashing Pumpkins
If they thought it was a 4/5, they should have let it be. That was a perfectly good opinion. Then the backlash started, and they dropped it from 4 stars to only 2. They did the same thing with Machina & Adore. Back in the day, they were rated higher, and now they've dropped the ratings. Why? So ridiculous. Just review the damn album, and keep it where you had it...
Rolling Stone is bullshit, hence why I don't follow them. To change their opinion on music because they're worried about their image. Pathetic.
I do like Stellar, Zeitgeist, 7 Shades Of Black, Tarantula and That's The Way (My Love Is). And then United States absolutely SLAYED live the two times I saw it. However, it stops there for me. I just find the remainder to be very mundane, unfortunately. It lacks the passion, in my eyes.
On the other hand, had they given the album a rawer (and darker) production like Billy originally intended, and they mixed his loud-ass vox down, then it would sit much better in the eyes of fans. It is my belief that Zeitgeist was a great record in theory, and intention, but BC & JC took the wrong paths with it. Had so much potential.
Still, I'd MUCH rather slap Zeitgeist on over essentially anything on rock radio. Though I find it to be Corgan's weakest offering, it is still MILES beyond any of the popular trash people call "music."