|
|
Kid IRA1 posted:BillyReznor88 posted:Kid IRA1 posted:Just picked up Adore, which is a lot better than people give it credit for. A few tracks could be cut, but otherwise, I rather like it.
On the other hand, Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness is really a bloated overrated lyrical hole. Cut it down to just the singles and you'd have a decent EP.
I couldn't agree with you more in regards to Adore, however I couldn't disagree with you more in regards to Mellon Collie. Are you honestly saying that 1979, BWBW, Tonight, Tonight, Thirty-Three, and Zero are the only "decent" songs on the album? Apparently you didn't listen to Thru the Eyes of Ruby. Mellon Collie is easily one of my top 5 albums, I realize this sounds cliche but it's like a journey everytime I listen to it. It's a really good mesh of hard rock songs (i.e. Fuck You (An Ode To No One), Jelly Belly, Tales of a Scorched Earth, XYU) along with the more slow beautiful songs (i.e. Tonight, Tonight, Beautiful, By Starlight.) I'm probably a bit bias here since Smashing Pumpkins are one of my favorite bands but I definitely think you need to listen to it again. I would like to take this time to say that I feel that Love is a very underrated Smashing Pumpkins song.
Actually, I would leave Zero for Pisces Iscariot too... think about the Broken EP. That would suck as an album. Well, not suck, but it would be just a giant rageful overkill. That is what Mellon Collie is for sadness, in my opinion. The lyrics for Siamese Dream were honest and open. The lyrics for Adore were darkly poetic. The lyrics for Mellon Collie and the the Machinas were more like pandering to teenage ennui which I guess is fine, if thats your thing. Zeitgeist just had weak songs, similar to Adore, except overwrought. Dont get me wrong, musically Mellon Collie is right next to Siamese Dream (although I prefer the layered guitar of Siamese Dream. Soma is beautiful.)
Also, Billy's in the news- defending the devil
Well, just so you realise that Corgan's manager is CEO of Ticketmaster...
But hey! Gish was a great album!!
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 03/15/2009 01:52PM by Guitars224.
|