Does anybody know what the whispers during A Stranger say?

I wish I had seen APC and NIN together, but I'm very much doubting that'll ever happen again.
It'd be nice if APC would rejoin, because I can't say I'm really enthusiastic about either of Billy or Maynard's side projects.

I've only heard Thirteenth Step.

i don't listen to it constantly because I want it to remain fresh whenever I hear it.

I kinda burned out YZ & Ghosts that way...

In my opinion A Perfect Circle is one of the best bands nowadays. It sorts of saddens me that they didn't do anything in a long time, but I'm sure they'll come back... sooner or later.

Love APC..got to see them open for NIN in '00. My only complaint is that they never made enough music

APC may come back....I hope so

I was completely taken over by MDN when it came out, and those songs meant more to me than I could ever describe..... I felt at the time that I was living those lyrics. ANyway life happened and I brought 13 step and EMotive but never sat down and listened to them. I did however sit down to watch the DVD when I brought it and all I remember was how weird it was and far from the life changing experience that MDN was.


I was cleaning out my closet last week and found a bunch of video tapes that I had saved but they weren't labeled so I had no clue what was on them (but I knew one of them was would be of the APC show in nyc in 2001.) I was right and I would love to share it w/ everyone but I am so technologically retarded, where would I even begin?

Anyway, the show brought back so many memories, my life back then was so lost and hurt *deep exhale* sooooo many regrets but the APC music is/was so healing. I haven't listened to MDN in YEARS but there was this one one piont in my life where I would live and breath it, I would have the cd player on repeat and listen over and over.... I NEVER did that with any other artist.

Watching the show reminded me that there is a lot of sensitively in their music and even though I love TOOL I never really connected to it on the same deep level, both bands have very little in common as far as I'm concerned. Also, this show was very no frills, it really made the music come alive even more b/c the music was the main focus and PAZ's violin solo's ~intense, calming, and simply beautiful.

I could go on and on about APC but basically I logged on here to see what's new with the band....

APC!! This band is so relaxing to listen to when it's raining outside. I don't understand how people say they can't tell the difference between this and Tool. Maynard's vocals are absolutely breathtaking with APC

A perfect circle is great stuff!
They make me think of a more rock oriented NIN.

I believe Thirteenth Step to be one of the greatest albums in my life time, and I wish some material would be produced by them, however Maynard is currently doing other (good admittedly, but not the level of APC or Tool) projects with Puscifer and so on.

My favourite song would have to be Pet, but by no means do I mean to diminish the appeal of any other great material they have released.

APC is a great band. One of my friends sent me their albums and they're just amazing.

The only thing that bothers me is that sometimes they combine song lyrics and put them in the same song...for the entire album. I never understood why. It's like listening to the same song but with a different beat behind it. But I can't understand WHY they'd combine the lyrics. Does anyone know?



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/10/2008 09:27AM by neoistheone4.

I got to see APC open for NIN in NOLA in 2000. you can hate me now

Mer De Noms favorite track: Magdalena
Thirteenth Step favorite track: The Noose
eMOTIVE favorite track: Passive

I have Mer De Noms and Thirteenth Step, I used to listen to them quite a bit but they kind of faded away for me. Never saw them live and don't really mind. I still love 3 Libras, an amazing song.

I recently got into this band. Mer De Noms is definitely their best, with eMotive close 2nd, but Thirteenth Step failed to impress me as much.

all the flesh posted:

APC!! This band is so relaxing to listen to when it's raining outside. I don't understand how people say they can't tell the difference between this and Tool. Maynard's vocals are absolutely breathtaking with APC

There is a huge difference if you understand the complexity of tool. Also Tool's tracks being 10 minutes fucking long and only comes out once every five years could give it away.

Sorry I have a love/hate relationship with Tool, I disagree with some of the ways they do things.

A Perfect Circle is cool thought, I enjoyed Mer de Norms a lot.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/10/2008 09:58PM by keithnoir.