The NIN Song Election - YEAR ZERO
 
Page: <  First... 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12...Last >

06/25/10 7:44 PM

well boo. i'm sad avott is gone so quickly. sad smiley

the good soldier.

 

06/25/10 9:57 PM

i'm tired of my violence in high def ultra-realism, so Survivalism



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 06/25/2010 11:50PM by fleighing.

 

06/26/10 2:05 AM

The Beginning of the End

 

06/26/10 5:33 AM

So Far:
The Greater good 6
Me I'm not 5
Beginning of the end 5
Vessel 4
Great destroyer 3
Meet your master 2
Good Soldier 2
God Given 1
Zero Sum 1
Survivalism 1
My violent heart 1

It's quite varied, with most songs being voted for. Only 'In this twilight' and 'The Warning' (YES!) have not been voted for. It looks like a three way race, with The Greater Good leading so far.

 

06/26/10 8:34 AM

hey, look at that; yet another challenging and heavily instrumental track is about to be voted off to an early death. what a surprise.

someone here keeps voting for The Greater Good because it makes them feel "crazy, and not in a good way". seems to me the very reason it should stay; that's how it's SUPPOSED to make you feel.

i've always imagined that song to be the sound of the effects of the fictional drug Parepin taking over your bloodstream; the song, with it's unusual instrumentation, syncopated beat and sinister vocals, gives the impression that something is not right here.

just by listening to The Greater Good, you get a vivid idea of just how bad things are in the world of Year Zero. to see it on the verge of elimination already is distressing.

ah well. my vote's God Given.

 

06/26/10 8:38 AM

DistantStorm posted:
hey, look at that; yet another challenging and heavily instrumental track is about to be voted off to an early death. what a surprise.

someone here keeps voting for The Greater Good because it makes them feel "crazy, and not in a good way". seems to me the very reason it should stay; that's how it's SUPPOSED to make you feel.

i've always imagined that song to be the sound of the effects of the fictional drug Parepin taking over your bloodstream; the song, with it's unusual instrumentation, syncopated beat and sinister vocals, gives the impression that something is not right here.

just by listening to The Greater Good, you get a vivid idea of just how bad things are in the world of Year Zero. to see it on the verge of elimination already is distressing.

Wow, if you hadn't have written all this, I'd have never known how I was SUPPOSED to feel when listening to the song. Thanks. eye rolling smiley

 

06/26/10 10:18 AM

DistantStorm posted:
hey, look at that; yet another challenging and heavily instrumental track is about to be voted off to an early death. what a surprise.

My thoughts exactly!

 

06/26/10 11:01 AM

EachWishRezigned posted:
Wow, if you hadn't have written all this, I'd have never known how I was SUPPOSED to feel when listening to the song. Thanks. eye rolling smiley


Year Zero is a concept album; i believe it was Trent's intent to have a range of different viewpoints, forming a narrative "snapshot" of this near future dystopia. each track of the album has a role to play in creating the overall portrait of the world.

The Greater Good, which is perhaps more of a soundscape than a song, seems like it was designed to make you uncomfortable, to convey an approximation of the twisted lengths that are being used to keep the populous in a mindless state of sedition.

so yeah, in terms of the larger narrative, i think Trent was going for a feeling of opression and unease with this track; the last thing you hear is him whispering over a sustained high pitched drone, like a sound in your head you can't control.

if a song like this makes you want to get up and do some dance aerobics, go for it. sounds like it has a pretty clear direction to me.

think what you will. and you're welcome. cool smiley

 

06/26/10 12:36 PM

I'm the one who says it makes me crazy.

You've got a point there that I agree with that it reps what's happening in YZ very well. It's doing its job and I think it's a super song. I am voting not on it's merits there at all, just that I don't want to go there personally that often.

Vote: The Greater Good

 

06/26/10 1:23 PM

Me, I'm Not

 

06/26/10 2:30 PM

My vote would have to be for The Warning - I skip it the most of what's left...

Everyone that wants to vote has done so so here are the results:



The Greater Good 7
Me, I'm Not 6
The Beginning of the End 5
Vessel 4
The Great Destroyer 3
The Good Soldier 2
God Given 2
Survivalism 1
My Violent Heart 1
The Warning 1
Meet Your Master 1
Zero-Sum 1



We will breathe The Greater Good in no longer!



THESE ARE THE REMAINING SONGS OF YEAR ZERO:


"The Beginning Of The End"
"Survivalism"
"The Good Soldier"
"Vessel"
"Me, I'm Not"

"My Violent Heart"
"The Warning"
"God Given"
"Meet Your Master"

"The Great Destroyer"

"In This Twilight"
"Zero-Sum"


In the words of lenny_VIE: Have Fun! smiling smiley



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 06/26/2010 02:35PM by jgrizzy89.

 

06/26/10 2:52 PM

Me, I'm Not

 

06/26/10 3:06 PM

Still voting for Zero-Sum

 

06/26/10 3:20 PM

Whiskers posted:
Still voting for Zero-Sum
Don't get your hopes up, you may be voting for the album winner here.

My vote: Me, I'm Not



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 06/26/2010 03:20PM by scott_pawsey.

 

06/26/10 3:35 PM

fuck this is really hard.

my bloated belly is definitely full, so again Survivalism. uh uh uh

 

06/26/10 5:04 PM

Me, I'm Not

 

06/26/10 4:20 PM

My Violent Heart

 

06/26/10 4:59 PM

my violent heart..

 

06/26/10 5:18 PM

Me, I'm Not

 

06/26/10 5:25 PM

God Given

 

06/26/10 5:29 PM

The....not so Good Soldier tongue sticking out smiley

 

06/26/10 5:32 PM

Me, I'm Not needs to stop...again

 

06/26/10 5:57 PM

scott_pawsey posted:
Whiskers posted:
Still voting for Zero-Sum
Don't get your hopes up, you may be voting for the album winner here.

My vote: Me, I'm Not

I know people have to be smart voters and side with the least favourite song thats getting a decent amount of votes sometimes, but it does say in the rules Vote for your least favourite...

I vote Meet Your Master.

 

06/26/10 5:58 PM

Me, I'm Not

 

06/26/10 6:00 PM

"The Beginning Of The End"

 

06/26/10 7:19 PM

Me, I'm Not

 

06/26/10 7:28 PM

My Violent Heart again.


Update:

Looks like a bit of a dogpile so far this round.

Me, I'm Not 6
My Violent Heart 2
Zero-Sum
Survivalism
God Given
The Good Soldier
Meet Your Master
The Beginning Of The End

 

06/26/10 7:46 PM

Me, I'm Not

 

06/26/10 8:31 PM

You guys are gonna kill Me, I'm Not before The Beginning of the End? That's just... wrong.

 

06/26/10 8:41 PM

The Great Destroyer

 
nin forums : Nine Inch Nails Discussion : The NIN Song Election - YEA...
Page: <  First... 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12...Last >
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum. Please log in at the top of the page.
 
terms of use | privacy policy