The NIN Song Election - THE WINNERS
 
Page: <  First... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15...Last >

11/08/10 11:34 PM

Right Where It Belongs

 

11/09/10 1:05 AM

BillyReznor88 posted:
BenAkenobi posted:
Hey people stop making so much ties! We could be done already. I'm not deciding between RWIB and Last. Both deserve to be on podium, instead of Ruiner winking smiley

What the hell did Ruiner do to you? Take you to a place you hoped it would never go and then fucked you up much more than we'll ever know? smiling smiley
To me it's simply not the best song from TDS and not better than remaining songs.
I explained my choice 2-3 pages back (even with examples of my preferred songs).
OK?
P. S.
and it doesn't even remotely seem i put it in any danger yet.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/09/2010 12:09AM by BenAkenobi.

 

11/09/10 12:17 AM

Fuck this!
I choose the rational way and view the case, that there are two more ballads in it. My vote for RWIB. *goes crying

 

11/09/10 12:18 AM

BenAkenobi posted:
BillyReznor88 posted:
BenAkenobi posted:
Hey people stop making so much ties! We could be done already. I'm not deciding between RWIB and Last. Both deserve to be on podium, instead of Ruiner winking smiley

What the hell did Ruiner do to you? Take you to a place you hoped it would never go and then fucked you up much more than we'll ever know? smiling smiley
To me it's simply not the best song from TDS and not better than remaining songs.
I explained my choice 2-3 pages back (even with examples of my preferred songs).
OK?
P. S.
and it doesn't even remotely seem i put it in any danger yet.

I understand. I think Ruiner and RWIB are the only songs that I've agreed with in the elections to be honest.

 

11/09/10 1:06 AM

Right where it belongs, sadly

 

11/09/10 3:01 AM

LAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAASSSTT

I vote Last

http://www.esoterica.fm.br/pictures2/James%20Last%20-%20Orchestra%20Classics%20vol.5.jpg

time for some obviously and soul despairingly bad jokes:

I hope this song isn't the last to go!

It should be the last in this race!

It's amazing this song has Lasted this long

BA DUM TISSSSSSSH!!!



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 11/09/2010 03:54AM by Churchy.

 

11/09/10 6:17 AM

Morning update, surprisingly NOT a tie heh:

Right Where It Belongs 11
Last 8

 

11/09/10 6:22 AM

BillyReznor88 posted:
BenAkenobi posted:
Hey people stop making so much ties! We could be done already. I'm not deciding between RWIB and Last. Both deserve to be on podium, instead of Ruiner winking smiley

What the hell did Ruiner do to you? Take you to a place you hoped it would never go and then fucked you up much more than we'll ever know? smiling smiley

I went to a coffeehouse on a date back in high school and 'The Downward Spiral' was in the jukebox. My date tried to play "Closer" but picked the wrong track and got "Ruiner". That made my day and ruined hers. I was like "Wow, impressive song choice." --until she blurted "Dammit, this isn't Closer"! ...Ahhh remember jukeboxes?


Wait what the F*#^#dogs am I talking about:

VOTE: Right Where It Belongs

OF COURSE

 

11/09/10 7:25 AM

LAST

 

11/09/10 7:31 AM

votiVe posted:
BillyReznor88 posted:
BenAkenobi posted:
Hey people stop making so much ties! We could be done already. I'm not deciding between RWIB and Last. Both deserve to be on podium, instead of Ruiner winking smiley

What the hell did Ruiner do to you? Take you to a place you hoped it would never go and then fucked you up much more than we'll ever know? smiling smiley

I went to a coffeehouse on a date back in high school and 'The Downward Spiral' was in the jukebox. My date tried to play "Closer" but picked the wrong track and got "Ruiner". That made my day and ruined hers. I was like "Wow, impressive song choice." --until she blurted "Dammit, this isn't Closer"! ...Ahhh remember jukeboxes?


Wait what the F*#^#dogs am I talking about:

VOTE: Right Where It Belongs

OF COURSE
I woul'd ve been like, "You're right, it's Ruiner, not Closer. Now shut the fuck up and listen, please."

 

11/09/10 8:54 AM

votiVe posted:

OF COURSE

A reference to M Bison I take it?

Anyway here's how my order would have gone!

1. Head Down
2. In This Twilight
3. Ruiner
4. Head Like A Hole
5. The Great Below
6. Right Where it Belongs
7. Now I'm Nothing
8. And All That Could Have Been
9. Last
10. 31 Ghosts IV

 

11/09/10 9:10 AM

If Last goes now, that pretty much means that Ruiner will be next, as it would be the oddball of the four remaining songs:

A piano ballad.
An emotional semi-acoustic ballad.
An emotional psuedo-symphonic ballad.
A pretty much straight-forward industrial track.


If RWIB goes, however, the mellow and aggressive tracks would be even, represinting two opposite sides of NIN. Also, Ruiner would have a better chance at winning.

 

11/09/10 10:04 AM

OK! That's it for the TIED ROUND! Here are the results:



TIED ROUND
Right Where it Belongs 12
Last 9

PREVIOUS ROUND
Last 11
Right Where it Belongs 11

Ruiner 3
The Great Below 1
And All That Could Have Been 1



The TIED ROUND has produced a decision - Right Where It Belongs takes is eliminated and takes Fifth Place!



THESE ARE THE REMAINING FAVORITE TRACKS OF THE NINE INCH NAILS COMMUNITY

"Last"
"Ruiner"
"The Great Below"
"And All That Could Have Been"



In the words of lenny_VIE: Have fun! smiling smiley



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/09/2010 10:05AM by jgrizzy89.

 

11/09/10 10:06 AM

Last fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff

 

11/09/10 10:07 AM

patrick_nicholas posted:
If Last goes now, that pretty much means that Ruiner will be next, as it would be the oddball of the four remaining songs:

A piano ballad.
An emotional semi-acoustic ballad.
An emotional psuedo-symphonic ballad.
A pretty much straight-forward industrial track.


If RWIB goes, however, the mellow and aggressive tracks would be even, represinting two opposite sides of NIN. Also, Ruiner would have a better chance at winning.
This is about the community's favourite NIN song. If it's a non-industrial track, why does it matter? All of these songs are amazing, even the "pseudo-symphonic" track that you described.

 

11/09/10 10:17 AM

^I didn't say I didn't like any of them. I just prefer his more aggressive/industrial tracks.


Also, my vote is for The Great Below. Again, I'm not saying I don't like it; it's just my least favorite of these.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 11/09/2010 10:24AM by patrick_nicholas.

 

11/09/10 10:31 AM

Are we considering TGB or AATCHB as the pseudo-symphonic one? I think AATCHB will win it all personally.


The Great Below can b-low me.

 

11/09/10 10:32 AM

Last

 

11/09/10 10:40 AM

SSquirrel posted:
Are we considering TGB or AATCHB as the pseudo-symphonic one?

TGB. AATCHB is the semi-acoustic one. I'm referring to TGB as pseudo-symphonic because is has a slightly symphonic feel to it, but most of the symphonic effects on The Fragile were done on guitars. It's only symphonic in feeling, but more ambient in nature, thus becoming pseudo-symphonic.

 

11/09/10 10:50 AM

my vote is for the great below

 

11/09/10 11:54 AM

Ruiner

 

11/09/10 11:21 AM

Last.

 

11/09/10 11:35 AM

LAST!

 

11/09/10 12:46 PM

Last

At this point, I'm pulling for Ruiner to win. RWIB was my former favourite though. sad smiley

 

11/09/10 12:52 PM

LAST.

 

11/09/10 2:28 PM

Churchy posted:
votiVe posted:

OF COURSE

A reference to M Bison I take it?

Not intentionally. I had no idea what/who that was until I just looked it up at Youtube. Funny. And weird. But mostly funny. But also a bit weird.

I was just going for emphasis.

VOTE: The Great Below

 

11/09/10 2:46 PM

Last

 

11/09/10 2:49 PM

And All That Could Have Been

 

11/09/10 2:53 PM

And All That Could Have Been

 

11/09/10 3:01 PM

They are all beautiful in their own way, but I'm going to go for And All That Could Have Been.

 
nin forums : Nine Inch Nails Discussion : The NIN Song Election - THE...
Page: <  First... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15...Last >
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum. Please log in at the top of the page.
 
terms of use | privacy policy