The NIN Song Election - THE WINNERS
 
Page: <  First... 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16

11/12/10 5:05 PM

RhettButler posted:
The Fragile is my favorite album, probably ever, along with Plastic Ono Band.
The Fragile is my favourite too. Second is Year Zero. Third is The Downward Spiral. Fourth is With Teeth. Do you see where this is going?

 

11/12/10 8:08 PM

ALRIGHT EVERYONE! THE WINNERS ELECTION IS OVER!!! Here are the results:



The Great Below 14
Ruiner 8



With the most votes this round, The Great Below takes the Second Most Popular Song spot, which leaves RUINER as THE MOST POPULAR NINE INCH NAILS SONG!!!!



HERE ARE THE FULL RESULTS OF THE WINNERS ELECTION
1. RUINER
2. The Great Below
3. And All That Could Have Been
4. Last
5. Right Where It Belongs
6. Head Down
7. In This Twilight
8. 31 Ghosts IV
9. Head Like A Hole
10. Now I'm Nothing




The Album Election is indeed the next election, however we have a short surprise for everyone before that election begins (which is tomorrow tongue sticking out smiley)....


ONE ROUND for a special vote on The Least Popular Nine Inch Nails Song! We will do just one round to find the ONE least popular song as opposed to making "The Best of the Worst" an actual election thread. This list consists of every song from the previous album/group elections that was voted off first.


THESE ARE THE LEAST FAVORITE TRACKS OF NINE INCH NAILS

"That's What I Get"
"Pinion"
"Big Man With A Gun"
"Starfuckers Inc."
"With Teeth"
"Hyperpower!"
"999,999"
"A Violent Fluid"
"March Of The Fuckheads"
"25 Ghosts III"




In the words of lenny_VIE: Have fun! smiling smiley



p.s. remember this is a BONUS ROUND and will only last ONE ROUND, therefore choose wisely and choose your LEAST FAVORITE track from this list so we can find the least favorite track opposite of Ruiner!



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/12/2010 08:13PM by jgrizzy89.

 

11/12/10 8:10 PM

I'm VERY happy with the results of this thread and these elections. I feel that this thing our forum has done is something worthy of reaching ears of importance. Hopefully our long hard battles over songs does not fall on deaf ears! May RUINER live in musical eternity. Amen. smiling smiley


My least favorite song on this list, and therefore my vote this round, HAS to be March of the Fuckheads



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 11/12/2010 08:12PM by jgrizzy89.

 

11/12/10 8:12 PM

wait what? that kinda confuzzled me....


uhhhh i choose With Teeth

 

11/12/10 8:17 PM

That's What I Get

 

11/12/10 9:24 PM

B10ndie927 posted:
wait what? that kinda confuzzled me....

At the end of the Ghosts election we had also done a single round between the first picked off from each of the EPs to determine which was the worst of that album. Since we have a best of the best, apparently J decided a quick single round to pick off the single worst. Since we don't need a full countdown, we just need to know the real stinker smiling smiley

I'm deciding between 5 right now. Starfuckers, With Teeth, 25 Ghosts III, A Violent Fluid, and March of the Fuckheads. Listening now.

Ok, I'll side along w/J for a change and go with March of the Fuckheads. The only thing that saved 25 Ghosts III is that sorta fly sound in there. Ties it nicely back to TDS for me.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/12/2010 09:34PM by SSquirrel.

 

11/12/10 10:01 PM

March Of The Fuckheads

 

11/12/10 10:07 PM

That's What I Get

 

11/13/10 1:10 AM

A violet fluid

 

11/13/10 12:33 AM

SSquirrel posted:
Technically, Still is the 2nd disc of the AATCHB live album. You had to buy it separately, but that was how it was billed. Considering most of the album is re-interpretations with only a few new tracks, it feels more like a remix disc than a proper studio album to me.

I actually bought And All That Could Have Been CD when it was first released and 'Still' was the limited edition bonus disc! But I think you can buy it separately now

 

11/13/10 12:36 AM

scott_pawsey posted:
My album ranking:

The Fragile
Year Zero
The Downward Spiral
With Teeth
Pretty Hate Machine
Ghosts I-IV
The Slip
Broken

Do you know what? I think my list is exactly the same as yours. I like YZ better than TDS also, and Broken just doesn't have as much appeal to me as the others!
EDIT sorry forgot to vote - March of the fuckheads



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/13/2010 06:46AM by WorzelG.

 

11/13/10 1:23 AM

"March Of The Fuckheads"

 

11/13/10 1:48 AM

Ruiner

Can't do an order of my preferred album. That depends on how I'm currently going somehow, when I pick a NIN album. Maybe I will figure out during the election, which one is my fav.

Starfuckers, Inc. as the worst from TF? Huuh? I like this track pretty much. It was always a hammer at partys and still gives me kicks.

March Of The Fuckheads

 

11/13/10 4:07 AM

WorzelG posted:
scott_pawsey posted:
My album ranking:

The Fragile
Year Zero
The Downward Spiral
With Teeth
Pretty Hate Machine
Ghosts I-IV
The Slip
Broken

Do you know what? I think my list is exactly the same as yours. I like YZ better than TDS also, and Broken just doesn't have as much appeal to me as the others!

Wow, my list is the same too I think smiling smiley

March Of The Fuckheads

 

11/13/10 5:18 AM

i'll just join you fuckheads marching right along smiling smiley

 

11/13/10 5:25 AM

wow, That's What I Get got MORE hate than Kinda I Want To? REALLY?!? that's just not right.

i'll go with Big Man With A Gun; the one and only Spiral track i would consistently skip over on my old cassestte version of the album, thus ensuring rewinding of side two every time to hear In A Warm Place. ah, for the days of the Walkman...



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/13/2010 05:26AM by DistantStorm.

 

11/13/10 6:05 AM

while i was driving into work i played our winners songs and boy did we do good! but then head down came on and i don't know why more don't LOVE this song. its got one of the best build-up and releases of any NIN song, i actually drove around the block so that i could get my 4 listens insmiling smiley

 

11/13/10 9:12 AM

DistantStorm posted:
wow, That's What I Get got MORE hate than Kinda I Want To? REALLY?!? that's just not right.

i'll go with Big Man With A Gun; the one and only Spiral track i would consistently skip over on my old cassestte version of the album, thus ensuring rewinding of side two every time to hear In A Warm Place. ah, for the days of the Walkman...
Kinda I Want To is my favourite PHM track. I don't understand the hate. It has a slight 80s feel to it, but not THAT bad. The chorus, although very short, is among my favourite NIN choruses.

 

11/13/10 9:15 AM

xcore posted:
Ruiner

Can't do an order of my preferred album. That depends on how I'm currently going somehow, when I pick a NIN album. Maybe I will figure out during the election, which one is my fav.

Starfuckers, Inc. as the worst from TF? Huuh? I like this track pretty much. It was always a hammer at partys and still gives me kicks.

March Of The Fuckheads
The live AATCHB version is even better in my opinion. It doesn't have the same energy in the chorus, but the acoustic portion is sooooo much more awesome. I feel like doing awesome stuff every time I hear it.

 

11/13/10 9:47 AM

scott_pawsey posted:
DistantStorm posted:
wow, That's What I Get got MORE hate than Kinda I Want To? REALLY?!? that's just not right.

i'll go with Big Man With A Gun; the one and only Spiral track i would consistently skip over on my old cassestte version of the album, thus ensuring rewinding of side two every time to hear In A Warm Place. ah, for the days of the Walkman...
Kinda I Want To is my favourite PHM track. I don't understand the hate. It has a slight 80s feel to it, but not THAT bad. The chorus, although very short, is among my favourite NIN choruses.

If I had to I would go with "That's What I Get".

scott_pawsey posted:
xcore posted:


Starfuckers, Inc. as the worst from TF? Huuh? I like this track pretty much. It was always a hammer at partys and still gives me kicks.

The live AATCHB version is even better in my opinion. It doesn't have the same energy in the chorus, but the acoustic portion is sooooo much more awesome. I feel like doing awesome stuff every time I hear it.

Agreed and signed.

 

11/13/10 9:56 AM

One of my favourite memories seeing NIN live was in Manchester when TR kept the 'Dont you, dont you, dont you..... chant going, but then said something about having heard European Football chants that we could do better.

grinning smiley

 

11/13/10 10:19 AM

FUCK YOU!

DON'T YOU DON'T YOU!


March of the fuck heads.


How can anyone now like That's what I Get?

I am going to listen to the live version from Hate 90'. Shame on you all.

 

11/13/10 12:06 PM

Yikes! So much going on. Very happy with the results of this election - but if we're moving to a new election - it needs a new thread!

That said - big man with a gun

 

11/13/10 12:23 PM

jenifer2126 posted:
Yikes! So much going on. Very happy with the results of this election - but if we're moving to a new election - it needs a new thread!

That said - big man with a gun

jenifer, we're not going to do a new thread for a single round vote. We did this at the end of Ghosts too. We'll be starting a new thread tonite when we start the album election

 

11/13/10 12:27 PM

Oh yeah, and an update. Buncha fuckheads in this town:

March Of The Fuckheads 9
That's What I Get 3
Big Man With A Gun 2
With Teeth
A Violent Fluid

 

11/13/10 12:32 PM

OK! That's it for the BONUS ROUND! Here are the results:



March Of The Fuckheads 10 (with phicry's vote below added on tongue sticking out smiley )
That's What I Get 3
Big Man With A Gun 2
With Teeth 1
A Violet Fluid 1



With a plurality of the votes, March Of The Fuckheads takes the not-so-coveted trophy for The Least Popular Nine Inch Nails Song! While it may be the least liked all around, this song is better than a lot of bands' best song. Words of wisdom tongue sticking out smiley

I do think it is a bit funny that The Most Popular Song and The Least Popular Song come from the same era...


NOW it's time to move on to...... THE ALBUM ELECTION!!!



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/13/2010 06:39PM by jgrizzy89.

 

11/13/10 3:17 PM

March Of The Fuckheads

 

11/13/10 8:37 PM

** hammers nails into that coffin with a wild swinging hammer and maniacal laugh **


March of the Fuckheads

 
nin forums : Nine Inch Nails Discussion : The NIN Song Election - THE...
Page: <  First... 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum. Please log in at the top of the page.
 
terms of use | privacy policy