Your controversial NIN opinions

Your controversial NIN opinions

Page: < First... 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 ...Last >

04/24/11 2:06 AM
Vidboy10 member Joined: 04/14/09 Posts: 29	BloodType89 posted: Probably not so controversial, but Starfuckers sucks and has no place on the Fragile. Well, I disagree that the song sucks. But yeah I agree, the style of Starfuckers.Inc doesn't really fit with the style of The Fragile at all.
Profile	back to top

04/24/11 9:51 AM
Sheepdean member Thug aim Joined: 11/27/07 Location: London Posts: 2,145	Vidboy10 posted: BloodType89 posted: Probably not so controversial, but Starfuckers sucks and has no place on the Fragile. Well, I disagree that the song sucks. But yeah I agree, the style of Starfuckers.Inc doesn't really fit with the style of The Fragile at all. I find it odd that people claim TF to be the best NIN album, but then say that one of the tracks doesn't work on it
Profile	back to top

04/24/11 5:22 PM
BloodType89 member is transfusing Joined: 04/05/11 Location: In Limbo Posts: 4,644	^^^ For me, that's because out of two disks, there is ONLY 1 track that I don't rate a 5/5... No other album get's that good of a review from me.
Profile	back to top

04/25/11 1:00 AM
RhettButler member Shipwrecked and Comatose Joined: 06/01/09 Location: Cardassia Prime Posts: 15,625	Vidboy10 posted: BloodType89 posted: Probably not so controversial, but Starfuckers sucks and has no place on the Fragile. Well, I disagree that the song sucks. But yeah I agree, the style of Starfuckers.Inc doesn't really fit with the style of The Fragile at all. SF hasn't always been my favorite song. Yet when I listen to The Fragile in its entirety, it seems to have its place, even though it might not seem to fit the sound and style of the album overall.
Profile	back to top

04/25/11 1:46 AM
BloodType89 member is transfusing Joined: 04/05/11 Location: In Limbo Posts: 4,644	It fit's fine until I hear the chorus... Then I just get annoyed with the redundancy. That's the word. StarFuckers is annoying not sucky.
Profile	back to top

04/25/11 10:26 AM
Metal_Incisor member Joined: 09/29/10 Posts: 3	SF almost seems like it needs to hang back with TDS, or that maybe it was meant to ease people into the more atmospheric sound of TF by giving it some common ground with TDS. I dunno, my two cents.
Profile	back to top

04/25/11 11:00 AM
Sheepdean member Thug aim Joined: 11/27/07 Location: London Posts: 2,145	Starfuckers is better than several tracks on The Fragile, and I don't think any NIN track is bad. My controversial opinion, it would seem
Profile	back to top

04/25/11 12:58 PM
Vidboy10 member Joined: 04/14/09 Posts: 29	Sheepdean posted: Vidboy10 posted: BloodType89 posted: Probably not so controversial, but Starfuckers sucks and has no place on the Fragile. Well, I disagree that the song sucks. But yeah I agree, the style of Starfuckers.Inc doesn't really fit with the style of The Fragile at all. I find it odd that people claim TF to be the best NIN album, but then say that one of the tracks doesn't work on it So? Trent even said himself that SF was a song he added to the album the last minute. To me SF should've been on something else.
Profile	back to top

04/25/11 2:04 PM
chrisfishlock member Joined: 11/28/07 Location: Reading UK Posts: 177	'Closer' is one of the worst NIN songs.
Profile	back to top

04/25/11 2:12 PM
Sheepdean member Thug aim Joined: 11/27/07 Location: London Posts: 2,145	Vidboy10 posted: Sheepdean posted: Vidboy10 posted: BloodType89 posted: Probably not so controversial, but Starfuckers sucks and has no place on the Fragile. Well, I disagree that the song sucks. But yeah I agree, the style of Starfuckers.Inc doesn't really fit with the style of The Fragile at all. I find it odd that people claim TF to be the best NIN album, but then say that one of the tracks doesn't work on it So? Trent even said himself that SF was a song he added to the album the last minute. To me SF should've been on something else. Well, it's not a perfect album if not every track fits exactly
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 9:05 AM
kenkopp69 member Joined: 10/13/10 Location: N.America Posts: 68	Piggy sucked, never could listen to it. Except the remix from FDTS (I accidentally bought the UK version T~T) Hurt is a good song with lots of meaning, but a bit too slow The Becoming has an annoying ass intro with that stupid bitch screaming (i cant pay attention to anything else Year Zero, Broken, and TDS were the best albums Get Down, Make Love is awkward and I skip it every time I hear it Half the ghosts are shit The Great Destroyer has the worst outro ever, starting where he screams the great destroyer The Line Begins to Blur is stupid and gives me a headache, it sounds like he's in a glass box theres a lot more, but those are the majority of my negative thoughts
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 10:07 AM
BRoswell member Not Easy Joined: 04/16/09 Location: Fort Wayne Posts: 282	kenkopp69 posted: The Becoming has an annoying ass intro with that stupid bitch screaming (i cant pay attention to anything else You do realize the screaming is in almost the ENTIRE song, right? posted: Get Down, Make Love is awkward and I skip it every time I hear it This guy must have a problem with women moaning and screaming :p posted: The Line Begins to Blur is stupid and gives me a headache, it sounds like he's in a glass box In a glass box?
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 11:51 AM
oitribe member Joined: 07/21/09 Posts: 83	kenkopp69 posted: Piggy sucked, never could listen to it. Except the remix from FDTS (I accidentally bought the UK version T~T) Hurt is a good song with lots of meaning, but a bit too slow The Becoming has an annoying ass intro with that stupid bitch screaming (i cant pay attention to anything else Year Zero, Broken, and TDS were the best albums Get Down, Make Love is awkward and I skip it every time I hear it Half the ghosts are shit The Great Destroyer has the worst outro ever, starting where he screams the great destroyer The Line Begins to Blur is stupid and gives me a headache, it sounds like he's in a glass box theres a lot more, but those are the majority of my negative thoughts come on show a little respect on a nine inch nails forum Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 04/26/2011 11:52AM by oitribe.
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 12:49 PM
TheKiw member Joined: 08/29/09 Location: Czech Republic Posts: 130	Vidboy10 posted: So? Trent even said himself that SF was a song he added to the album the last minute. To me SF should've been on something else. So? What kind of a reason is that? Are you implying, that the songs, that are added the first are the best ones? I'm not saying, that SF is awesome/sucks, but the fact that it was added at the last minute doesn't have to say anything about the song.
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 2:28 PM
Vidboy10 member Joined: 04/14/09 Posts: 29	Sheepdean posted: Well, it's not a perfect album if not every track fits exactly I never said TF was a perfect album, to me perfect doesn't exist. Everything tries its best, TF is the best NIN album no doubt about it but its no way in hell the best album ever.
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 3:32 PM
beachpoet member Joined: 05/16/10 Location: virginia beach Posts: 202	"getting smaller" is one of nin's best songs.
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 5:35 PM
scott_pawsey member Just zeroes and ones Joined: 09/03/08 Location: Ontario - Canada Posts: 4,225	Vidboy10 posted: Sheepdean posted: Well, it's not a perfect album if not every track fits exactly I never said TF was a perfect album, to me perfect doesn't exist. Everything tries its best, TF is the best NIN album no doubt about it but its no way in hell the best album ever. *disagrees*
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 5:53 PM
BloodType89 member is transfusing Joined: 04/05/11 Location: In Limbo Posts: 4,644	^^^^ I second that.
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 6:00 PM
ninevoltz member Joined: 04/26/11 Posts: 9	Salem is ready to replace NIN. Fuck YES. I can't help but feel like they are the logical replacement. FUCKIN' AWESOME * 1000 Finally some fresh fucked up music. I could kiss them! Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 04/26/2011 06:04PM by ninevoltz.
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 6:10 PM
Sheepdean member Thug aim Joined: 11/27/07 Location: London Posts: 2,145	ninevoltz posted: Salem is ready to replace NIN. Fuck YES. I can't help but feel like they are the logical replacement. FUCKIN' AWESOME * 1000 Finally some fresh fucked up music. I could kiss them! That is awful, derivative crap. I don't think that's controversial either
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 6:10 PM
ninevoltz member Joined: 04/26/11 Posts: 9	Dave Sardy did their studio work!
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 6:14 PM
ninevoltz member Joined: 04/26/11 Posts: 9	posted: That is awful, derivative crap. I don't think that's controversial either Derivative CRAP? Are you insane? The freshest shit I've heard in YEARS
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 6:19 PM
ninevoltz member Joined: 04/26/11 Posts: 9	I've been trying to get them noticed by WMG, I know a guy with Roadrunner who might be interested in them. He was with TVT when Trent said "Fuck STEVE"
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 6:26 PM
Sheepdean member Thug aim Joined: 11/27/07 Location: London Posts: 2,145	Learn to edit your own posts. And if you want to talk about this crap band, do it in the proper forum
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 6:29 PM
ninevoltz member Joined: 04/26/11 Posts: 9	Sheepdean posted: Learn to edit your own posts. And if you want to talk about this crap band, do it in the proper forum Which forum do you recommend, lord Sheepdean? Trent has said that he doesn't plan any new releases. What are we to listen to? Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 04/26/2011 06:31PM by ninevoltz.
Profile	back to top

04/26/11 6:31 PM
Sheepdean member Thug aim Joined: 11/27/07 Location: London Posts: 2,145	The music forum, for one. [forum.nin.com] Or, if it's actually your band and you're just trying to flog it, [forum.nin.com] Seriously, not hard to scroll down
Profile	back to top

04/27/11 1:48 AM
BenAkenobi member 999998 Joined: 04/13/08 Location: Chekhov Posts: 2,080	i heard Salem remix of Interpol song and it's so forgettable, sorry
Profile	back to top

04/28/11 8:39 AM
sunuv member Joined: 09/20/08 Posts: 74	ninevoltz posted: posted: That is awful, derivative crap. I don't think that's controversial either Derivative CRAP? Are you insane? The freshest shit I've heard in YEARS That shits super fresh. And I ain't funnin'.
Profile	back to top

04/28/11 5:36 PM
YKWYA member All these moments...... Joined: 11/27/07 Posts: 1,142	Sheepdean posted: Learn to edit your own posts. And if you want to talk about this crap band, do it in the proper forum Thank you.
Profile	back to top

04/28/11 6:13 PM
TheUnfan member Joined: 03/18/11 Posts: 44	I like NIN but for the most part I'd rather listen to Exotic Birds and Slam Bamboo. Trent is a fantastic pop musician.
Profile	back to top

Page: < First... 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 ...Last >

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum. Please log in at the top of the page.

terms of use | privacy policy