Your controversial NIN opinions

Your controversial NIN opinions

Page: < First... 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 ...Last >

12/21/11 3:47 PM
patrick_nicholas member Former New Yorker Joined: 05/06/09 Location: Blackwater Park Posts: 43,791	EDIT: I think the opinion I originally posted here sounded a bit too controversial. Edited 4 time(s). Last edit at 12/22/2011 04:47PM by patrick_nicholas.
Profile	back to top

12/22/11 11:56 PM
BenAkenobi member 999998 Joined: 04/13/08 Location: Chekhov Posts: 2,081	patrick_nicholas, i have respect in your opinion which you have removed
Profile	back to top

12/22/11 11:12 PM
RhettButler member Shipwrecked and Comatose Joined: 06/01/09 Location: Cardassia Prime Posts: 15,825	SalavanteK posted: Sheepdean posted: I consider Broken an LP. I'm with you there too. I actually dislike Broken being labeled as an EP. When I think second NIN album, I hardly think TDS. I kind of see it as album 1.5
Profile	back to top

12/29/11 3:02 PM
guitarninslim member Joined: 12/27/11 Location: WayfarAway from the crowd Posts: 43	Ahhh this is where i put things people don't want to hear. ooook. Yep, don't like the immigrant song remake. Sorry.
Profile	back to top

12/29/11 3:04 PM
guitarninslim member Joined: 12/27/11 Location: WayfarAway from the crowd Posts: 43	patrick_nicholas posted: OnslaughtSix posted: LEONCIORULES posted: My controversial opinion is that I hope TR never pays much attention to this thread because most of the controversial opinions posted here are wrong. XD For instance: there are not bad or boring NIN's albums or songs and Starfuckers is a great song that actually fits perfectly in TF. XD I could be all day replying to every controversial opinion posted here, but I'll just say you all are wrong because it's easier and faster. XD /FANBOY. Opinions, by definition, cannot be wrong. Grow up. Exactly. KMOS92 posted: I don't enjoy Further Down The Spiral that much. Same here. While the downward spiral may be one of the best albums ever made, further down the spiral is not. agreed.
Profile	back to top

12/29/11 3:07 PM
guitarninslim member Joined: 12/27/11 Location: WayfarAway from the crowd Posts: 43	Does anyone else think that THINGS FALLING APART is one of NIN best??? I sure do
Profile	back to top

12/29/11 3:11 PM
guitarninslim member Joined: 12/27/11 Location: WayfarAway from the crowd Posts: 43	jimfear posted: Hate to say it, but I've never been a big fan of The Wretched. Mid-tempo, lacking much in the way of dynamics. The piano line is great, but I've always been a bit bored by the song as a whole. The Frail, however is gorgeous. THE CLOUDS WILL PART AND THE SKY CRACKS OPEN AND GOD HIMSELF WILL REACH HIS FUCKING ARM THROUGH JUST TO PUSH YOU DOWN JJJUST TO HOLD YOU DOWN, STUCK IN THIS HOLE WITH THE SHIT AND THE PISS AND ITS HARD TO BELIEVE IT CAN COMEDOWN TO THIS, BACK AT THE BEGINNING, SINKING, SPINNING. THAT IS WHY THAT SONG IS AMAZING. In my opinion
Profile	back to top

12/29/11 3:20 PM
RhettButler member Shipwrecked and Comatose Joined: 06/01/09 Location: Cardassia Prime Posts: 15,825	guitarninslim posted: Does anyone else think that THINGS FALLING APART is one of NIN best??? I sure do I enjoy it, but wouldn't say it was one of their best.
Profile	back to top

12/29/11 5:47 PM
phicry7220 member Joined: 11/29/07 Location: Virginia Posts: 1,297	This is a big one.....I don't think they're gonna win lots of awards for this score. ( I hope they do) I don't think Fincher used it as well. there were many tracks not used, and some repeated. I think the score stands more as an album on it's own. ( an epic album! think Ghosts) With TSN I hear those songs and remember the movie...it's not like that with tgwtdt....but I have only watched it once Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 12/29/2011 06:04PM by phicry7220.
Profile	back to top

12/29/11 10:36 PM
SalavanteK member Get out! Joined: 03/13/11 Posts: 662	guitarninslim posted: Does anyone else think that THINGS FALLING APART is one of NIN best??? I sure do As far as remix albums go, I'd definitely agree with you. It's among my favorites.
Profile	back to top

12/30/11 1:35 AM
DrVertigo member Joined: 08/31/09 Location: England Posts: 367	phicry7220 posted: This is a big one.....I don't think they're gonna win lots of awards for this score. ( I hope they do) I don't think Fincher used it as well. there were many tracks not used, and some repeated. I think the score stands more as an album on it's own. ( an epic album! think Ghosts) With TSN I hear those songs and remember the movie...it's not like that with tgwtdt....but I have only watched it once Agreed. With TSN, it felt like the music made the movie; it would be greatly diminished with anything else (especially if they'd used the studenty pop-rock themes that were originally intended). With Dragon Tattoo, the music is every bit as amazing and evocative, yet it doesn't gel as much into the movie. A lot of that is down to utilisation, as you say. I think it does have one fundamental failing, though, in that it's rarely particularly dark - that's something that surprised me from my first listen. It's more mournful than anything else, and perhaps feels more like a mood setter than a direct score. Watching the film, I felt a lot of the grimmer scenes could have been greatly heightened by stronger, more sinister music. /Controversial opinion...
Profile	back to top

01/02/12 5:44 AM
suicidegrrl member suicidegrrl Joined: 09/29/10 Location: Wales%2C uk Posts: 41	garymiley posted: The Perfect Drug was an abomination. "steps back in amazement!" I challenge you to a duel sir....pistols at dawn....just name the place....!
Profile	back to top

01/02/12 5:47 AM
suicidegrrl member suicidegrrl Joined: 09/29/10 Location: Wales%2C uk Posts: 41	Posted twice by accident coz this I phone app is glitchy, not as bad as some have said tho.....there r 2of every thread in the forum listings and my posts don't say they've loaded when they have (generating error msg) leading me to (needlessly) post twice) anyway, I'm going off the subject here. Surprised to see quite a few ppl don't like eraser, F@£&ing love those tracks myself Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 01/02/2012 05:56AM by suicidegrrl.
Profile	back to top

01/02/12 6:12 AM
RhettButler member Shipwrecked and Comatose Joined: 06/01/09 Location: Cardassia Prime Posts: 15,825	suicidegrrl posted: garymiley posted: The Perfect Drug was an abomination. "steps back in amazement!" I challenge you to a duel sir....pistols at dawn....just name the place....! I can see not liking it, but "abomination"? Which reminds me that I need to put the LH soundtrack on my i-tunes.
Profile	back to top

01/02/12 11:01 AM
suicidegrrl member suicidegrrl Joined: 09/29/10 Location: Wales%2C uk Posts: 41	indeed you do sir, it is a wonderful thing in this vast desert of non-wonderful things......] Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 01/02/2012 11:03AM by suicidegrrl.
Profile	back to top

01/03/12 1:34 PM
Mark_Stafford member Joined: 01/03/12 Posts: 8	Probably an odd place to have my first post but here goes; Sunspots was the best track on With Teeth. Reptilian > Reptile. Self Destruction Final is a hell of a lot of fun, especially that complete breakdown around 1:37. 10 Miles High probably makes it into my top 3. I like Piggy more than Hurt, I like I Do Not Want This (that outro!) more than Closer, and The Becoming beats the hell out of everything else on Downward Spiral. The Space In Between would also be in top 3 (if I expanded my top 3 to include HTDA, obviously). If I'm in the right mood, I prefer the Dub Mix (yep) to the single of Hand That Feeds Ghosts 14 got even better when it became Magnetic. Pilgrimage might be my #1. Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 01/03/2012 01:35PM by Mark_Stafford.
Profile	back to top

01/03/12 4:13 PM
RhettButler member Shipwrecked and Comatose Joined: 06/01/09 Location: Cardassia Prime Posts: 15,825	^I thought that "Sunspots" was one of the best songs on WT.
Profile	back to top

01/03/12 4:39 PM
HurtNoMore member Anduril Joined: 09/17/08 Location: MA Posts: 1,069	RhettButler posted: ^I thought that "Sunspots" was one of the best songs on WT. I second that. However, Pilgrimage is probably my least favorite song on any full length NIN release.
Profile	back to top

01/04/12 3:21 AM
BenAkenobi member 999998 Joined: 04/13/08 Location: Chekhov Posts: 2,081	However, Pilgrimage is probably my least favorite song on any full length NIN release. {added you to list of my enemies} {{okay, i have no such list but it physically pains me that the song showing such immense passion gets so frowned upon}} Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 01/04/2012 02:35AM by BenAkenobi.
Profile	back to top

01/04/12 10:18 AM
HurtNoMore member Anduril Joined: 09/17/08 Location: MA Posts: 1,069	BenAkenobi posted: {added you to list of my enemies} Good, because when I will see you in hell I'm going to point out that Pilgrimage is on repeat for eternity.
Profile	back to top

01/05/12 3:04 PM
guitarninslim member Joined: 12/27/11 Location: WayfarAway from the crowd Posts: 43	RhettButler posted: ^I thought that "Sunspots" was one of the best songs on WT. I loved With Teeth. While it wasn't very heavy and didn't contain some of that Reznor anger we all love, it was just a different kind of NIN. All the love in the world, sunspots, the line begins to blur=goooooood. Right where it belongs is probably one of the best songs of all time, any genre, and timeline, forever.
Profile	back to top

01/05/12 9:46 PM
phicry7220 member Joined: 11/29/07 Location: Virginia Posts: 1,297	HurtNoMore posted: RhettButler posted: ^I thought that "Sunspots" was one of the best songs on WT. I second that. However, Pilgrimage is probably my least favorite song on any full length NIN release. I second both of these statements. I love "Sunspots" actually one of my all time favorite songs...and Pilgrimage is one of my least favorite NIN songs in general.
Profile	back to top

01/06/12 6:55 AM
TheWollenstubby8th member I sure like Prent Resner! Joined: 07/27/11 Location: Trents porn collection Posts: 11	The Fragile>>>>TDS
Profile	back to top

01/06/12 9:08 AM
HurtNoMore member Anduril Joined: 09/17/08 Location: MA Posts: 1,069	We wouldn't be here if it wasn't for this guy: [en.wikipedia.org] ie, PHM-(Purest Feeling)=Flood Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 01/06/2012 09:10AM by HurtNoMore.
Profile	back to top

01/06/12 9:17 AM
Sheepdean member Thug aim Joined: 11/27/07 Location: London Posts: 2,148	HurtNoMore posted: We wouldn't be here if it wasn't for this guy: [en.wikipedia.org] ie, PHM-(Purest Feeling)=Flood Nor without this wanker [en.wikipedia.org].
Profile	back to top

01/06/12 11:03 AM
HurtNoMore member Anduril Joined: 09/17/08 Location: MA Posts: 1,069	^You think? You can't replace a manager? Flood's impact on the sound of the first three NIN albums cannot be understated, and he was sorely missed on The Fragile.
Profile	back to top

01/06/12 11:17 AM
Sheepdean member Thug aim Joined: 11/27/07 Location: London Posts: 2,148	Malm was more than just a manager, he was the spine of NIN's non-musical side. He was a thief and a liar, but he still knew how to roll. Flood had little or no impact on PHM and wasn't even on Purest Feeling. And he got Trent to not put out Just Do It, which means one more NIN song we don't have
Profile	back to top

01/06/12 11:32 AM
HurtNoMore member Anduril Joined: 09/17/08 Location: MA Posts: 1,069	Sheepdean posted: Flood had little or no impact on PHM Are you sure about this? As far as I know he was responsible for a lot of refinements we hear between PHM and purest feeling, which is pretty important. He's listed as the producer.
Profile	back to top

01/06/12 11:36 AM
Sheepdean member Thug aim Joined: 11/27/07 Location: London Posts: 2,148	As one of the producers: I know he was the sole one for Down In It, aside from that, it was a mishmash of production from as many producers as one would expect of a dubstep track!
Profile	back to top

01/10/12 12:58 AM
nickheer member Joined: 01/09/12 Posts: 2	- I really dug With Teeth, without caveats – I think The Slip and Ghosts are dramatically better albums than Pretty Hate Machine - Every tour had its merits, but I echo some of the previous posters in this 20-page volume and I think Wave Goodbye produced some of the finest shows in Nine Inch Nails' history - Where Is Everybody? is a good song, but the remix on Things Falling Apart is truly excellent, and the only remix I prefer over the original. Plank, walking it. Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 01/10/2012 01:02AM by nickheer.
Profile	back to top

Page: < First... 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 ...Last >

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum. Please log in at the top of the page.

terms of use | privacy policy