marodi

The Duchess of Otterland
Joined: 12/02/07
Location: Quebec Canada
Posts: 2,234
|
zensauna posted:patrick_nicholas posted:This version is cool, but I still prefer the original. I find it more powerful as Robert Plant, with his instantly recognizable voice, displays a wider vocal range than Karen O does; and Jimmy Page delivered one of the greatest and most instantly recognizable riffs in rock music. When played on a synth, like on this version, it feels more like a remix than a cover.
NOT saying this version is bad, just saying I strongly prefer the original.
I've got many friends who share this view. While I'm not going to "choose sides", I'd still like to point out that making a "pure" cover would probably not have seen artistically interesting, the guitar-playing would have been instantly compared to the original and so, the resulting version was probably the only (or one of the few) way to make the cover unique - ie by converting the guitar riff to a synth part.
Somehow, I agree with both of you.
It must have been terrifying to cover a Led Zeppelin song (I know I would have been scared shitless). I don't think there's a singer in the world right now who can be compared with Robert Plant; in my eyes, he is a living god.
At the same time, I very much like this cover. I think it is the best way that it could be done by retaining elements from both Led Zeppelin and from Trent. Being a fan of both, it makes me a happy baby otter. 
|