The NIN Song Election - Ultimate Reznor Edition
 
Page: <  First... 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33...Last >

04/18/12 8:33 AM

Burn, goddamnit!

 

04/18/12 8:48 AM

Last

Sorry about my misvotes - my tiredness and lack of appearance here is to blame!

 

04/18/12 9:08 AM

I now have company for Last

I admit calling it generic was wrong, but I've never really FELT the Broken EP, not one of my favourite albums

 

04/18/12 10:00 AM

Burn
http://content9.flixster.com/question/44/67/51/4467511_std.jpg

 

04/18/12 10:04 AM

Ruiner

 

04/18/12 10:14 AM

WorzelG posted:
I've never really FELT the Broken EP, not one of my favourite albums

Watching Wish world premiere was my first taste of NIN. I was a sophomore in high school. Broken was given to me that Christmas, I even still have the longbox. I also have one of those first copies w/the 2nd 3.5" cd that has Suck and Physical on it, instead of having tracks 98 and 99. There's a reason I'm attached to that album. It's a great big blast of anger and certainly works well for those times. So does Manson's ACS tho heh.

 

04/18/12 10:22 AM

Is there something awesome about Metal and Dead Souls that I'm just not seeing?

My vote is for Dead Souls

 

04/18/12 12:14 PM

pyr0kinetic posted:
Is there something awesome about Metal and Dead Souls that I'm just not seeing?

Yes. The original by Joy Division and teh NIN cover of Dead Souls are both great songs. They're a more basic track, but good. Metal is very repetitive and simple and that is part of what makes it great. Original by Gary Numan is very close to what Trent did.

 

04/18/12 1:47 PM

I have all the love in the world for all the love in the world, but unfortunately love is not enough.

 

04/18/12 9:36 PM

KMOS92 posted:
Burn, goddamnit!

I knoooow!!!

It was soooo close.

This is my fault... I voted Right Where it Belongs on the last round, then I saw that All The Love in the world had 3 votes and Burn had 2, and I wanted to save all the love in the world (for some god forsaken reason), so I bumped Burn to 3, then all of a sudden 4 votes for demon seed came out of nowhere!!! if I knew that I would have voted for all the love in the world instead of Burn during that round to save Demon Seed...

Next thing you know, I wake up, and it's Demon Seed VS Burn...

So, my clever vote to save "all the love in the world" worked, but sacrificing a much better song - Demon Seed...

and here we are now again All the love in the world is on the brink of extinction and even me teaming up and voting Burn for this round won't save it...

well, I voteBurn anyway, even though it has no chance in hell at this point.

I'd like to see you make it another round Burn, see ya next round Burn, see ya next round...

 

04/19/12 6:50 AM

All the Love in the World, which really is a fantastic album opener, was not the popular one this round. That was the first song from With Teeth to go.

ATLITW 6
Burn 3
Ruiner 2
Last 2
Terrible Lie
Dead Souls




THESE ARE THE TRACKS for the Ultimate Reznor:


Misc Tracks:

2. Metal
3. Dead Souls

Non-Album Tracks:

1. And All That Could Have Been
2. Burn

The Slip:

1. Head Down
2. Echoplex

Year Zero:

1. In This Twilight
2. Zero-Sum
3. The Warning

With Teeth:

1. Right Where It Belongs
2. The Line Begins To Blur

The Fragile:

1. The Great Below
2. Somewhat Damaged
3. We're In This Together

The Downward Spiral:

1. Ruiner
2. The Becoming
3. Reptile

Broken:

1. Last
3. Happiness In Slavery

Pretty Hate Machine '89: (Terrible Lie was #3 on '89 and #2 on 2010, so removed dupe)

1. Head Like A Hole

Ghosts I-IV:

1. "31 Ghosts IV"

Pretty Hate Machine '10:

1. Sin
2. Terrible Lie

The Mixes: (Top mix from each election only)

Eraser (album)
Mr Self Destruct (album)





In the words of lenny_VIE: Have fun smiling smiley

 

04/19/12 6:51 AM

Terrible Lie

 

04/19/12 7:51 AM

METAL

--ManBurning : I think you are required to change your username to ManNotBurning if you keep voting Burn.

 

04/19/12 8:43 AM

It really burns him up

 

04/19/12 9:28 AM

LAST



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 04/19/2012 10:52AM by fleighing.

 

04/19/12 9:45 AM

Last

It's not that I dislike it but I just don't feel it is up there with the rest of the tracks (as well as AATCHcool smiley

 

04/19/12 9:47 AM

Metal

 

04/19/12 10:55 AM

Ruiner

 

04/19/12 11:12 AM

votiVe posted:
METAL

--ManBurning : I think you are required to change your username to ManNotBurning if you keep voting Burn.

Metal?? See, that's why I have to keep voting Burn, because you want to kill off an amazing song like that!

I don't vote burn by choice, I vote it to get results as it's the "worst of what is being voted" so I am trying to team up with fellow voters based on the worst vote being voted to save my personal faviourtes.

I still have 6 songs worse than Burn on my list, but nobody would start voting them, in fact if I started voting most of these I would be guaranteed a punch in the face...

Right Where It Belongs
Eraser (album)
Mr Self Destruct (album)
Head Like A Hole
31 Ghosts IV
Echoplex

I'm gonna save my vote for tonight, let some more votes pile up, see what I need to try and save later tonight.



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 04/19/2012 11:54AM by ManBurning.

 

04/19/12 12:08 PM

Ruiner

 

04/19/12 12:10 PM

Head Down

 

04/19/12 1:01 PM

Burn. By choice.

 

04/19/12 1:41 PM

ManBurning posted:
31 Ghosts IV
Echoplex
I could go with these
or Ruiner...or Last,..or throw my vote away for the warning again -.- which are all worse than burn imo

well, I guess I´ll wait some more tonight

 

04/19/12 2:01 PM

Last

 

04/19/12 2:05 PM

ok, ok


Last

 

04/19/12 3:01 PM

Metal, Ghosts, Burn, are all prime targets for me.

The only thing I disagree with so far is Ruiner. That probably is in my top 10.

 

04/19/12 5:52 PM

Couldn't see it at work, so just saw it. Love the Fight Club pic HNM smiling smiley

 

04/19/12 7:02 PM

Everytime I see that scene I think to myself, "wow Fincher is being a show off", followed by, "I guess it's okay to show off if you are that good"

Sorry for the flip on burn, but I listened to metal again and felt it was worse.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 04/19/2012 07:07PM by HurtNoMore.

 

04/19/12 10:00 PM

Ok this is kind of ironic since I was complaining about people voting metal above, but I have to vote METAL as well.

I need to save LAST, last is higher on my list than Metal.
And after listening to Metal again, it's nothing overly amazing, plus it's not even his song, it's a cover.

 

04/20/12 7:03 AM

I can't save Last w/o endangering Metal, so I guess I have to let another Broken track go. Moving right along....

Last 4
Metal 3
Ruiner 2
Terrible Lie
Head Down
Burn




THESE ARE THE TRACKS for the Ultimate Reznor:


Misc Tracks:

2. Metal
3. Dead Souls

Non-Album Tracks:

1. And All That Could Have Been
2. Burn

The Slip:

1. Head Down
2. Echoplex

Year Zero:

1. In This Twilight
2. Zero-Sum
3. The Warning

With Teeth:

1. Right Where It Belongs
2. The Line Begins To Blur

The Fragile:

1. The Great Below
2. Somewhat Damaged
3. We're In This Together

The Downward Spiral:

1. Ruiner
2. The Becoming
3. Reptile

Broken:

3. Happiness In Slavery

Pretty Hate Machine '89: (Terrible Lie was #3 on '89 and #2 on 2010, so removed dupe)

1. Head Like A Hole

Ghosts I-IV:

1. "31 Ghosts IV"

Pretty Hate Machine '10:

1. Sin
2. Terrible Lie

The Mixes: (Top mix from each election only)

Eraser (album)
Mr Self Destruct (album)





In the words of lenny_VIE: Have fun smiling smiley

 
nin forums : Nine Inch Nails Discussion : The NIN Song Election - Ult...
Page: <  First... 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33...Last >
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum. Please log in at the top of the page.
 
terms of use | privacy policy