I already have my "ultimate Reznor" picked out, as like I previously said, I sat down and ordered these songs from best to worst at the very start, and I am just crossing the songs that get taken off on by one on my list.

My top 5 is actually pretty close. if multiple of my top 5 remain when we are down to top 5 or top 10, it's going to be very hard to choose between these to be honest. I have a general idea of what I want to win, it could change, but it definatly is classic reznor material.

My top 5 has a song from The The Downward spiral era, The Pretty Hate Machine era, the Slip era and 2 b-sides.

As mentioned by Fleighing, it's going to get very hot 'n heavy in here when we reach the top 10, and goddamn am I ever ready for it, it's gonna be a blast.

But only if more people came to vote, we only have 12-15 people voting on a good day. That's hardly a good census for picking an ultimate reznor track, How can we get more people invovled? I came here from the ETS post that was made, so that was a start.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 03/27/2012 10:02PM by ManBurning.

The first FDTS track (and only version of Piggy) is now gone from our list. The Big Bad Wolf huffed and he puffed and he voted you off

Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now) 5
Intriguing Possibilities 2
Terrible Lie
The Warning
Burn
Ruiner
Closer (album)
Down In It
10 Miles High


THESE ARE THE TRACKS for the Ultimate Reznor:


Misc Tracks:

1. Now I'm Nothing
2. Metal
3. Dead Souls

Non-Album Tracks:

1. And All That Could Have Been
2. Burn
3. Non-Entity

The Slip:

1. Head Down
2. Echoplex
3. Demon Seed

Year Zero:

1. In This Twilight
2. Zero-Sum
3. The Warning

With Teeth:

1. Right Where It Belongs
2. The Line Begins To Blur
3. All The Love In The World

The Fragile:

1. The Great Below
2. Somewhat Damaged
3. We're In This Together

The Downward Spiral:

1. Ruiner
2. The Becoming
3. Reptile

Broken:

1. Last
2. Gave Up
3. Happiness In Slavery

Pretty Hate Machine '89: (Terrible Lie was #3 on '89 and #2 on 2010, so removed dupe)

1. Head Like A Hole
2. Down In It

Ghosts I-IV:

1. "31 Ghosts IV"

The Social Network:

1. Pieces Form The Whole
3. Intriguing Possibilities

Pretty Hate Machine '10:

1. Sin
2. Terrible Lie

Purest Feeling:

2: The Only Time
3: Sanctified

Further Down the Spiral:

Ruiner (Version)
Heresy (Version)

Things Falling Apart:

1. Slipping Away
2. The Wretched (Keith Hillebrandt Mix)
3. The Great Collapse
3. 10 Miles High (Keith Hillebrandt Mix)

Yearzeroremixed:

the great destroyer (modwheelmood)

The Mixes: (Top mix from each election only)

Closer (album)
Eraser (album)
Mr Self Destruct (album)
The Perfect Drug (NIN mix)




In the words of lenny_VIE: Have fun

Hoo boy, it just started to get tough.

The Great Destroyer (modwheelmod remix)

Intriguing Possibilities



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 03/28/2012 08:38AM by serenityangel.

Ruiner

The Perfect Drug (NIN mix)

ManBurning posted:

Nooooo, Intriguing Possibilities must be saved!!!!
I just listened to Intriguing Possibilities and it's awesome, so beautiful!

Agreed, and I do wonder if someone out there is tracking down NIN forumites and slipping LSD in their morning vodka.

But perhaps the best way of saving IP isn't voting the awesomest version of Sanctified (by around three hundred thousand awesometres), which nobody else has voted for. Make sure you stay well-hydrated, chum.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 03/28/2012 12:13PM by DrVertigo.

ManBurning posted:

Nooooo, Intriguing Possibilities must be saved!!!!

There isn't even a valid contender yet... just mismatched random votes...
I'm even on the verge of voting Terrible Lie. I just listened to
Intriguing Possibilities and it's awesome, so beautiful!

I vote Sanctified

I'm going to vote Intriguing possibilites just to spite you for voting Sanctified.

Down In It

^^^i agree that IP should be saved, but disagree with most of your what is worse choices, so I'm joining DrVertigo with

The Great Destroyer (MWM remix) - sorry Alessandro!

Yep, I don't want IP off just yet, so gonna have to go with the MWM Great Destroyer mix...think that means it's tied!

Had some time to kill at lunch, so have now put all the remaining songs into four categories of approx 10 each from best to worst, then tactical voting becomes a bit easier...

Actually a)I didn't have to change my vote to save anything, b)I hate tie rounds, so I'm not super likely to change to force a tie unless it's something I personally want saved.

EDIT: Somehow I miscounted and it's actually a 5-5 tie. I'm not switching my vote at this point to keep it from being a tie round. Looks like we lose another day heh.


The Great Destroyer (modwheelmod remix) 5
Intriguing Possibilities 5
Terrible Lie
Ruiner
The Perfect Drug (NIN mix)
Burn
Down In It


Vote for your LEAST favorite between:
The Great Destroyer (modwheelmod remix)
Intriguing Possibilities



In the words of lenny_VIE: Have fun



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 03/29/2012 07:59AM by SSquirrel.

Intriguing Possibilities

votiVe posted:

Whu?!!! I guess I lost track with all the vote changing?

TGD- ManBurning, Xcore, Worzel, Simonn, DrV

IP- Votive, HurtNoMore, SerenityAngel, Fleighing, LittleDreamer

Was there a re-districting issue?

That's really weird cuz I would swear I re-counted that one a couple of times. Ok. Tie round after all. Changing it up.


OK, tie round. Change votes if needed.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 03/29/2012 08:00AM by SSquirrel.

I hope they tie again and both get kicked off.

IP